Bibcode
DOI
Socas-Navarro, H.; Trujillo Bueno, J.
Bibliographical reference
Astrophysical Journal v.490, p.383
Advertised on:
11
1997
Citations
42
Refereed citations
33
Description
We present a critical analysis of linearization and preconditioning, the
two most used approaches proposed for achieving the required linearity
in the iterative solution of the multilevel transfer problem. By
distinguishing from the outset between the response of the radiation
field to the source function and opacity perturbations, we are able to
demonstrate that if the linearization strategy, on which the local
approximate Lamda -operator option of the multilevel transfer code MULTI
is based, is applied neglecting the terms coming from the response of
the radiation field to the opacity perturbations, one then recovers the
same equations obtained using the preconditioning technique of Rybicki
& Hummer. It is also shown that if this preconditioning technique is
applied taking into account the response of the radiation field to both
the source function and opacity variations, one then ends up with the
same equations found via the linearization method. Thus these two
approaches to the numerical solution of the multilevel transfer problem
turn out to be essentially the same, because similar equations are
obtained if the same information is taken into account. Finally, it is
pointed out that, if one wishes to guarantee positivity for the atomic
level populations, it is necessary to neglect the terms associated with
the response of the radiation field to the opacity perturbations.
Neglecting such terms does not deteriorate the convergence rate of
multilevel transfer methods that make use of a local approximate
operator.